The Seed Patent Case: Bowman v. Monsanto - Podcast
Intellectual Property Practice Group and George Mason University School of Law's Center for the Protection of Intellectual Property Podcast
June 3, 2013Jorge Contreras, Gregory Dolin, Hans Sauer, Sean O'Connor, Dean A. Reuter
To listen, please right click on the audio file you wish to hear and then select "Save Link As..." or "Save Target As..." After you save the audio file to your computer, you can then listen to it in your audio player of choice.
The Seed Patent Case: Bowman v. Monsanto - MP3
Running Time: 00:59:15
On May 13, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Bowman v. Monsanto, an extremely important case about the scope of patent rights in both promoting new biotech research and ensuring that the fruits of these labors are secured to the firms that sell and license this new technology. In her opinion for a unanimous Court, Justice Kagan stated that Monsanto's patent rights in genetically engineered soybean seeds were not "exhausted" by the first sale of these seeds to a farmer. In this case, Bowman replanted follow-on generations of seeds naturally produced by the plants that grew from first-generation seeds first purchased from Monsanto. Monsanto expressly restricted this type of "re-use" of the genetically engineered seeds, because it maintained that it could not recoup the hundreds of millions of dollars in R&D investments required to create this technology without such restrictions. The Court agreed, and while it seemed to establish a clear rule that will spur the ongoing creation and distribution of genetically engineered inventions in the green and biotech revolutions, there remain important questions about the scope of licensing rights in patented technology generally and the scope of patent protection over forms of life. This panel of experts will discuss the Bowman decision, its role in the ongoing policy debates over patented innovation, and the implications it has for future innovation.
- Prof. Jorge Contreras, American University Washington College of Law
- Prof. Gregory Dolin, University of Baltimore School of Law
- Mr. Hans Sauer, Deputy General Counsel, Biotechnology Industry Organization
- Moderator: Prof. Sean O'Connor, University of Washington School of Law
- Introduction: Mr. Dean Reuter, Vice President and Practice Groups Director, The Federalist Society